From Subject Matter Expert to Leader: Letting Go of Having All the Answers
- The Leadership Mission
- Jun 11
- 3 min read
Leadership doesn’t always start with authority—sometimes it starts with expertise. Many new leaders earn their role by being high performers, the go-to subject matter expert who can solve problems, troubleshoot under pressure, and deliver consistent results.
But here’s the hard pivot: once you step into leadership, being the expert is no longer your job. Unlocking the expertise of others is.
This shift can feel destabilizing. You might wonder: If I’m not the one with all the answers, how do I prove my value? If I step back from the work I know best, what do I actually do?
These are the right questions. Because moving from subject matter expert to leader isn’t about doing less—it’s about leading differently.
Why the Expert Role Can Hold Leaders Back
As a subject matter expert, you get rewarded for mastery. You’re expected to have the answers. You build your confidence around competence.
But leadership is about something else entirely: creating environments where other people can thrive. If you keep inserting yourself as the fixer, the smartest voice in the room, or the one who always swoops in with the solution, you unintentionally:
Disempower your team
Limit their growth
Bottleneck decision-making
Burn yourself out
Your team doesn’t need another expert. They need a leader.
The Shift from Doing to Developing
Leadership begins when you stop proving your own capability and start believing in others’.
This means:
Asking questions instead of giving answers
Creating clarity instead of solving every problem
Coaching performance instead of rescuing work
You don’t disappear from the technical side. But you reposition your role. You go from architect to guide. From driver to director. From knower to unlocker.
Case Study: The Trusted Tech Lead
Andre was the top developer on his team for three years. When he was promoted to team lead, he kept doing what he was good at: code. He reviewed every pull request. Jumped in on late-night bugs. Took over tricky assignments.
His team, once eager, started deferring to him. They stopped trying bold ideas. Progress slowed. Andre was exhausted.
His turning point came in a one-on-one when a team member said, "I want to lead something, but it feels like you already have it all covered."
That comment landed. Andre stepped back, started asking more than telling, and let go of needing to be the smartest person in the room. Six months later, his team was faster, more creative, and more engaged. And he finally had time to think strategically.
Why This Shift Is Emotionally Hard
Letting go of expertise can feel like letting go of identity. If you’ve always been the subject matter expert, stepping back feels risky. You might fear losing respect, relevance, or control.
But here’s the truth: people may admire your knowledge, but they follow your trust. They remember how you made space for their growth. How you believed in them when they were still learning. That’s the leadership that leaves a legacy.
Case Study: From Sales Star to People Leader
Jill had been the top sales performer for three consecutive years. When promoted to lead the team, she kept hitting her personal targets—but her team lagged.
Her manager pulled her aside: "You’re still a great individual contributor. But that’s not your role anymore."
Jill had to learn to lead pipeline reviews, coach calls, and build systems—not close deals herself. She shifted from "Let me do it" to "Let me help you do it."
It took time, but her team grew—and so did she. She realized her impact was no longer measured in deals, but in people.
How to Lead Beyond the Subject Matter Expert
Normalize Not Having All the Answers Say "I don’t know" with confidence. Model curiosity. Invite others to contribute ideas.
Shift from Answers to Questions Instead of saying, "Here's what I think," ask, "What options are on the table? What do you think we should try?"
Coach the Thinking, Not Just the Outcome When someone struggles, resist jumping in. Ask guiding questions that help them think critically.
Celebrate Effort and Ownership Reward risk-taking, learning, and initiative—not just polished results.
Practice to Try: The Facilitation Flip
In your next team meeting, challenge yourself not to offer the first solution. Instead:
Ask each person for input
Reflect back themes you’re hearing
Let silence do its work
You’re not abdicating leadership. You’re amplifying it by inviting others in.
Closing Reflection
The move from subject matter expert to leader isn’t a loss of identity. It’s an expansion.
You stop leading from what you know. You start leading from who you empower. And in that shift, your influence grows far beyond what your expertise alone could ever achieve.
Comments